On today’s episode: we’ll debunk the notion of the romance of life at sea by revealing why every famous mariner you ever heard of probably smelled like sun-baked sewage and ripe boils; we’ll discuss the only character in this show’s history that we’ve compared with Jim Jones, Machiavelli, and Charles Manson; and we’ll answer the age-old question, “how many people would you kill for a Klondike Bar”.
And if you were listening to this on Patreon: I don’t know how many people died at your summer camp, but you would hear about the most insanely dangerous sleep away camp of all time; and you would hear the tale about a dire set of circumstances that led to the world record for the most people to be killed and eaten inside an area roughly the size of a school bus.
If this were any other story, the instigating shipwreck would be an incredible disaster on its own. As it happens, I barely remember there was a shipwreck. Of all the stories we have covered, this is clearly going to be one of the most unhinged. Plus, you know my rule. If I’m telling you a story more than 400 years old, you know it has to be good. It’s lawless as hell, and the record keeping wasn’t great, but the drama is unstoppable. Until the end, when some people would die terribly in this dry run of the Lord of the Flies, while others would experience a little surgery with a hammer and chisel because of it.
It is with no small amount of joy that I announce we will be adding a retrospective show called Doomsday Aftermath shortly that will allow you to re-experience early episodes with remastered audio, and a load of memories and behind-the-scenes stuff from the creation of that episode, and an update on what we’ve learned about the disaster itself since originally airing it.
–––––
THANK YOU. Most shows survive at the whim of production companies and corporate sponsors, built from the top down. Doomsday doesn’t exist because some network exec believes in it – it exists because actual people do. It's built from the bottom up, and it’s been my privilege to bring you these stories. Just you, me, and a microphone.
I don’t do this for you, so much as I do this because of you. If you'd like to support the show at Buy Me A Coffee, or join the club over at Patreon for AD-FREE EPISODES, LONGER EPISODES, EXTRA CONTENT, all that good stuff
All older episodes can be found on any of your favorite channels
Apple : https://tinyurl.com/5fnbumdw
Spotify : https://tinyurl.com/73tb3uuw
IHeartRadio : https://tinyurl.com/vwczpv5j
Podchaser : https://tinyurl.com/263kda6w
Stitcher : https://tinyurl.com/mcyxt6vw
Google : https://tinyurl.com/3fjfxatt
Spreaker : https://tinyurl.com/fm5y22su
RadioPublic : https://tinyurl.com/w67b4kec
PocketCasts. : https://pca.st/ef1165v3
CastBox : https://tinyurl.com/4xjpptdr
Breaker. : https://tinyurl.com/4cbpfayt
Deezer. : https://tinyurl.com/5nmexvwt
Follow us on the socials for more
Facebook : www.facebook.com/doomsdaypodcast
Instagram : www.instagram.com/doomsdaypodcast
Twitter : www.twitter.com/doomsdaypodcast
TikTok : https://www.tiktok.com/@doomsday.the.podcast
Safety google off. We'll talk soon. And thanks for listening.
Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/doomsday-history-s-most-dangerous-podcast--4866335/support.
Imagine being nearly Tetris to death in the throes of a massive shipwreck. Now, imagine yourself sitting on a deserted island and watching as the remains of that ship are slowly beaten to death by the waves and thinking, well, at least things can't get any worse. Then you meet the surviving crew and wonder if it's too late to swim back to the wreck. One minute. Hello and welcome to Doomsday, history's most dangerous podcast. Together, we are going to rediscover some of the most traumatic, bizarre, and awe-inspiring but largely unheard of or forgotten disasters from throughout human history and around the world. On today's episode, we will debunk the notion of the romance of life at sea by revealing why every famous mariner you've ever heard of probably smelled like sun-baked sewage and ripe boils. We'll discuss the only character in this show's history that we have compared with Jim Jones, Machiavelli, and Charles Manson. And we will answer the question, how many people would you kill for a Klondike bar? And if you were listening to this on Patreon, I don't know how many people died at your summer camp, but you would hear about the most insanely dangerous sleepaway camp of all time. And you would hear a tale about a dire set of circumstances that led to the world record for the most people to be killed and eaten inside an area roughly the size of a school bus. This is not the show you play around kids or while eating or even in mixed company. But as long as you find yourself a little more historically engaged and learn something that could potentially save your life, our work is done. So, with all that said, shoo the kids out of the room, put on your headphones and safety glasses, and let's begin. We've talked about the age of exploration before. It was this incredible period of maritime history that spanned the 15th through the 17th centuries, where people were going gaga for everything from exotic goods and new trade routes to new mythological mer-creatures appearing on world maps. Now, in the modern age, there will be skeptics who don't believe that we ever went to the moon in 1969, and I am wagering that there would have been plenty of people in 1629 that refuse to believe the very idea that a ship could set sail and somehow, over the course of months, survive thousands of miles of trans-oceanic travel. History should be filled with stories more like, And then just three weeks into his journey, Christopher Columbus arrived back at his home port, delirious and dry-barfing on the dock. For me, the words no and thanks rarely sit so snugly together. But of course, what's the reason mankind has always pushed itself into the unknown? Moolah, or even just the promise of Moolah. European kingdoms regularly traded travel time and sometimes the lives of entire crews, funding waves of ships, all for the chance to earn unimaginable wealth catering to Europe's boner for exotic Asian delights like pepper or cinnamon or silk or porcelain or textiles or teas. A single cargo of any one of these could make investors lottery rich. The Dutch East India Company, for example, became one of the most powerful corporations in the history of the world doing exactly this, and we'll come back to them. And when I say powerful, I want you to imagine a company that owned their own private military, and that governed territories overseas, and built forts, and sometimes they kicked ass. We've all seen paintings of regal fur-coated Europeans landing and humbling the natives with their almost alien-like presence, but allow me to paint a different, less glowing picture of the realities of life at sea. I want you to picture early explorers as thin and gaunt and weathered, all sunburnt and covered in sores or bubbles of puke or bites from insects and vermin. Now all it needs... throw in a beard, and clothes that were smellable at a distance, and a display of summer teeth from scurvy. If you've never heard that term, it means summer here, summer there. Which is a shame, because in a journey like this, you are going to need all the teeth you can to deal with the meal plan. hard biscuits, salted meat, dried peas, and beer. And by beer, think of more of a skunky fermentation that offered more flavor than bacteria. And I'm not saying that all of this is bad. However, there are stories of people who chose rats as snacks. A little scurvy would be one thing, but dysentery, typhus, tuberculosis, and any number of fevers or infections could wipe out dozens of crew and passengers at a spell. Then there's the ship. A ship of this era would carry not just hundreds of unwashed people, but there would also be livestock and bilge water and molding wood and rotting food. And don't forget the poop. After months of hardship, the first priorities after reaching land were in order. Fresh water, fresh food, sleep, medical treatment, and, time permitting, burying the dead. And the best part? You get to do the whole thing again on the way home. So, yes, it was dangerous. And for the crew of today's story, it's true, we are going on a voyage together, this will be the biggest understatement that you will hear all day. Pack your Imodium. your favorite sunscreen, and some anti-scurvy lozenges, for today, we will be boarding a Dutch East India Company merchant vessel called the Batavia. She carries company officials and soldiers and sailors and craftsmen and passengers, all looking to start a new life overseas, along with cargo and silver to trade for whatever earned the most coin back in Europe. The Batavia had been constructed in Amsterdam only a year earlier, in 1628, and was among the newest and most sophisticated ships of her day. Picture a six-story wooden building laid on its side, fitted with sails the size of tennis courts, armed with cannons, and carrying enough silver to buy a small town. If you like thick girls, The Batavia's most striking feature, even more than the sails, was her stern. She had a towering rear section that rose dramatically above the water. It looked like a kind of a multi-story wooden palace, covered in enough regal decoration and embellishment and sculpted flourish to make a show of wealth and prestige. Basically, it was a real tell-me-you-have-wealth-and-prestige-without-telling-me-you-have-wealth-and-prestige situation. It was definitely designed to make any port that she sailed into stop, stare, and say, look at these a * * holes. Real Pirates of the Caribbean stuff. The Batavia was about 11 Dodge Caravans long, that's about 56 meters or 184 feet, and she displaced about 600 tons. And people always wonder what that means. All it means is that, in the same way your hand would displace water from a cup The Batavia displaced about 600 tons of water out of the way, that's about 280 Dodge Caravans worth of water. The Dutch East India Company, or VOC for short in Dutch, maintained a fleet of ships moving goods between Europe and Asia, and this made them one of the richest companies in the world. The Batavia served the VOC as a combination merchant ship slash warship She was armed to the teeth and well prepared to interrupt any hostile encounter with pirates or foreign naval forces mid-sentence. Forty cannons is a lot of teeth. I'm sure that won't be a problem for us today, as we, together with 341 other souls, join her on her maiden voyage to her namesake in Indonesia, the capital of Batavia. There were about 40 civilian passengers on board, 30 of which were women and children. And then another hundred were soldiers. The VOC controlled a trading empire that stretched all the way from South Africa to Sri Lanka and everywhere in between. So replacement soldiers were constantly needed to guard forts, protect warehouses, suppress local rebellions, you know, that kind of thing. In 1629, The Dutch Republic was in the middle of a little something called the Eighty Years War against Spain and they were constantly mixing it up with Portugal and Spanish forces all across Asia, so between that and the tropical diseases and accidents, like I said, replacements. And I was personally amazed to learn that there were 200 crew on board. Apparently, A vessel this size, at this point in history, needed an entire army of sailors to work the sails, navigate, maintain lookouts, make rope, repair the hull, lift chains, drop anchors, move cannonballs, and everything else you can imagine. From cooking, sort of, to cleaning, sort of. I heard it described as a floating construction project, with muscle power replacing cranes and winches and hydraulics. So really, the Batavia is a combination of cargo ship, passenger ship, troop transport, and floating Brinks truck. Do you know what a gilder is? It's a silver coin, and since people preferred payment in precious metals, the VOC sent a constant stream of them to pay for the goods that made them so rich back home. Now, a typical laborer or worker might make maybe a gilder a day. but that Batavia was carrying 250,000 of them. It would take one of those workers 685 years to make that much. Today, that much silver would be worth about 25 million. Batavia was the Dutch colonial capital in Indonesia, slash administrative headquarters for Asian logistics, and it also had the vaults needed to hold all that booty and the soldiers to protect it. So we're going to be traveling across some of the most treacherous water in the world aboard a ship that's never been sailed on one of the longest and most demanding journeys a human being could undertake in the 17th century. Yeah, I forgot to mention the trip is more than 20,000 kilometers or 12,000 miles and will take about nine months. On the chilly morning of October the 20th, 1628, We weigh anchor and leave our mooring heading out to cross the North Sea before turning southward into the Atlantic. And we might as well take a moment to meet a few of the people that have made this trip possible. The most senior VOC official aboard today was Commander Francisco Pelsart. He'd been with the VOC for 13 years and had complete authority over this expedition, outranking even the captain of the ship. a man named Arianne Jacobs, who did not care for that. Turns out the both of them had a pretty long-standing feud. On an earlier voyage together in the East Indies, Jacobs kinda snuck off the boat, got super drunk, misbehaved, and had to be publicly reprimanded by Pelsart in front of VOC officials. Jacobs was a career sailor, and he did not like taking guff from stuffed shirts or administrators from head office, and certainly not about how to run a ship. He didn't care for Pelsart's more by-the-book approach, and he shared his grumblings with others, and we will come back to that. Geronimus Cornelis was Pelsart's deputy and the other highest ranking VOC officials, and we don't know a lot about him other than he joined the VOC to escape bankruptcy and other unnamed persecutions, whatever that means. Our plan today is to stay relatively close to shore as we begin to trace Europe's western coast south. The first weeks of the voyage saw heavy grey skies, rough seas, and frequent storms, which pretty much common in these parts. This is the part of the trip where we will end up doing our most robust barfing. We actually almost ended our trip on day one. There was a storm that whipped up around us and then drove us onto a sandbank off the Dutch coast before we had to be refloated and just started the whole thing over. Things will calm, sort of, as we exit the North Sea and continue past France and Spain, where all we have to worry about now are sudden weather changes, giant waves, powerful storms, and cannonballs. Past all this, we enter into a region nearing the Canary Islands, where it's actually kinda nice. Warm winds, favourable currents, a chance to turn off the bar for a minute. But as we approach Cape Verde and Africa... and things kick up again with a sudden tropical squall. It takes just under two months to make it to this point where we're nearing the equator, and we find ourselves transitioning into a very different kind of experience. This is the part of the trip where we will do our most robust moaning. At the equator, winds could just abandon you, leaving you to drift under a blazing sun in 35 degree heat, that's 95 Fahrenheit, with heavy humidity for days or weeks while you watch your sails hanging limp and your supplies dwindling. They call this the intertropical convergence zone, but sailors called it the doldrums. And if ever there was a point for a fellow passenger to have a psychotic break and try to kill you, this is definitely one of them. But don't worry. At one point, a violent thunderstorm will spring up and push us south and we can continue. It'll take us till the end of December to travel the entire length of Africa before we finally round the Cape of Good Hope at the southern tip and into the Indian Ocean. Sailors called it the Cape of Bad Storms. The Atlantic and Indian Oceans meet at a spot that has claimed thousands of ships, and many call this the most dangerous part of the journey. For the Dutch East India Company alone, about 3% of their vessels never make it. But for the 97% that do, congratulations, and we are now halfway to our destination. The Batavia reached Table Bay at the Cape of Good Hope on April the 14th. The Batavia reached Table Bay at the Cape of Good Hope on April the 14th. Cape Town, as we know it today, wouldn't become a thing until 1652. For now, it was just this really well-known place for passing ships to anchor up and trade with the locals. It was also Jacob's chance to steal a boat, visit other ships, get super drunk, pissing off a lot of captains, and once again, leaving Pelsar to field all the complaints. After eight days on shore, we departed for Indonesia. But the drama won't stop. And I didn't mention it before, but of the civilian passengers, some of them were quite hoity-toity. Take Lucretia van der Meilen, for example. She was 27 years old, and her wealth came from diamonds of all things, and she was on her way to join her husband in Batavia. Captain Jacobs was one of those guys who thinks no means maybe, and he put the moves on her a couple times. However, she was all, Ew, servant, barf for me, which he did not take kindly. And then, to make matters worse, in the spirit of so many 1980s movies, Jacob saw Lucretia having dinner with Commander Pelsart, and steam came out his freaking ears, and under his breath, he swore bloody revenge. Lucretia was later strolling the deck when a group of masked men abducted her, partially stripped her down, manhandled her, and then smeared her entire body with a homemade mixture of warm tar and feces. Why? Follow me now. Jacob's thinking. was that Pelsart so freaked out he would completely overreact, he'd punish huge numbers of the crew, and then that would piss them off enough that they would be thinking about mutiny. But Pelsart was mature enough to recognize a trap when he smelled one, and the whole Lucretia Van Dam Island assault thing smelled like a trap, and tar, and poo. And he investigated it, but he put off making any arrests until they reached Indonesia. Thus, mutiny averted. To say the rest of the journey was tense barely covers it. Indonesia is a kind of an island nation in the same way that the Bahamas are. Indonesia is basically a sprawling nation made up of about 17,000 islands, stretching from the Pacific all the way to the Indian Ocean. Today, it's the fourth most populous country in the world, with over 280 million people just behind India, China, and the US. And I kinda get it. I mean, it might be swelteringly hot, but it's gorgeous. Tropical rainforests, coral reefs, beaches, and some of the planet's richest biodiversity. The capital is Jakarta. Now, back in the day, it was called Jayakarta or Jakarta. That was until about 10 years earlier when, in 1619, the Dutch came and decided, you know, let's just nuke it from offshore. It's the only way to be sure. and then came in and rebuilt it as Batavia. And all we have to do to get there is cross some of the breeziest terrain in the world. The winds here do tend to dramatically shorten our journey, because this far south, there are no large land masses to block winds. I mean, if you just look at a map, it's basically like a band of nothing all the way around these southern latitudes. No large landmasses to block any of the winds. So they tend to grow unwieldy. We're trading time for the occasional gale and rough seas that pound on us for days. And yeah, fair trade. We continue to blow east across the Indian Ocean, and all we have to do is figure out when to hang a left and start heading north. Here's the thing. We might not see land again for weeks or months, so we're going to have to navigate by tracking imaginary map lines called latitudes and longitudes. If you knew your position on both of those, you could easily pinpoint yourself onto a map. But in 1629, sailors didn't have a lot of real foolproof ways of calculating longitude. Think of longitude as east-west or left to right on the map. Latitudes were the up and down lines, and they were fairly easy enough to figure out using the stars. But longitudes, basically until the age of marine chronometers, were pretty guessy work. And then add to that, math is hard. Jacobs had been responsible for tracking our position using dead reckoning, measuring time against what we think our speed to be to estimate our position. And at this point in our long journey from South Africa to Indonesia, his math placed us about 965 kilometers or about 600 miles from Australia. And the date was June the 3rd, 1629. And it was late, so Jacobs put down his abacus and his wine bucket and got some sleep while the Batavia continued clocking along. And I should probably point out, We are under full sail and being driven by a strong wind. Around 4 o'clock the next morning, the 4th of June, lookouts up in the rigging reported that they were seeing white water ahead. The simplest explanation was just the reflections of the brightness of the moon, and Jacobs assumed as much. What else could it possibly be? I mean, yes, it could also be surf breaking over a shallow reef, I suppose, but there's only one real way to find out. And when it happened... The crash was sudden and violent. Welcome to Australia! Sort of. See, back in 1629, whatever this odd, barely memorable landmass was, it was not called Australia. What it was, was a massive continent-sized area inhabited by hundreds of unique Aboriginal nations, each with their own cultures and histories going back millennia, and each surviving in one of the most dangerous environments in the world. But as far as Australia went, from the European point of view, it was just something that they had already sailed by, but largely ignored for hundreds of years. In 1606, Dutch navigator Willem Janszoon made the first recorded European landing on the Australian mainland at Cape York, pretty much at the most northern tip of the whole continent. Him and his crew explored the coast, stopped on shore a few times, you know, mapping and looking for anything that they could sell, when they met their first Aboriginal party, who originally welcomed them with open arms, peacefully. But after a few incidents of violence and some unanticipated horizontal boogie committed against their women, the locals decided killing nine of Jianzun's crew made a pretty good start, and off they went, and they called this place Cape Turnaround. Ten years later, a Dutch captain named Dirk Hartog landed on the west coast. Hartog wasn't an explorer by trade, He had kind of arrived by accident, and he only ended up staying a few days, kind of like Chevy Chase at the Grand Canyon, if you get the reference. Before he left, he took a silver platter, flattened it out with a hammer, carved We Was Here into it, and then nailed it to a pole. And today, that spot is known as Inscription Point, and it remains the oldest surviving physical evidence of a European in Australia. But Technically, back then it was known as Terra Australis Incognita, which is Latin for Unknown Southern Land. And hey, we beat Captain Hook here by 141 years. However, we too have discovered it the hard way, by running right into it. Or more specifically, we ran into the Hotman Abrelos Islands just off the western coast. We snagged onto an outcrop of coral hidden just below the surface that tore out our rudder, followed by the bow body-slamming onto what would become Morning Reef. And because we were going full speed, our initial impact drove us up and onto the reef. And the ship may have stopped moving, but the passengers and crew and everything else on board didn't know that and wanted to keep moving forward. And about 100 people did not survive the experience. Survivors immediately scrambled onto deck with some climbing up into the rigging or clinging to the ship for dear life. She was surrounded by pounding surf and every new wave helped impale her deeper onto the reef. Things like cannons and heavy cargo were thrown overboard in order to try to lighten her, but because the tide had been falling, it didn't really help. We sailed into this thing full speed because we believed we were almost a thousand kilometers away, when in reality, it turns out we had actually only been about 40 miles or 64 kilometers away. The reef was inhospitable, but it was surrounded by small islands of coral rubble. with barely a scrap of vegetation and zero protection from the sun or wind or salt or any of the elements really, and it was small enough to walk across in a few minutes, but it was better than the reef. About 180 passengers, including the women and children, were ferried to a flat expanse of what today we call Beacon Island, and people began immediately digging for water and searching for anything useful, but they found very little. So provisions were painstakingly hauled from the ship, but again, not enough. And because the Batavia did not disappear immediately like most shipwrecks, it became a kind of a haunted house. It even had passengers still on board who'd been too afraid to swim, and others who were scurrying around in the shadows trying to loot booze or anything else they could find, until the Batavia eventually broke up completely and even the hermits were forced to abandon her. About 280 people found themselves stranded and off course by about 2,000 kilometers from their intended destination. And no spoiler here, but the good times are now over. So what happened? Well, if you mean about the wreck, math was hard and then they crashed. But if you mean after the wreck, well, here we go. They needed rescuing, so after four days, Francesco Pelsort made an uncomfortable choice. He would take about 48 sailors, officers, and passengers in the only seaworthy longboat they had and go looking for help. Of course, deciding to do this quietly while people still slept was going to become an issue. The date was June the 8th, and a lot of survivors woke that morning thinking that they had been abandoned to die. They left, but they didn't just head off for Indonesia. They started by heading to the Australian mainland, since it was the closest possibility of food and water. Now, I don't know if you've been to the edges of Western Australia, but it is not exactly a buffet of riches for the hungry stomach. So, they re-boarded their ship and set a heading for Batavia. The city, not the wreck. And we'll check back in with them in about another month or so, just to see how they're doing. With all the leadership gone, Cornelis effectively took control of the situation as the next highest ranking officer remaining, and it wasn't going to be easy. Initial searches of nearby islands turned up bupkis. They did manage to salvage barrels of water from the ship, but not nearly enough, and no pop tents or first aid kits or anything like that. They were gonna have to do for themselves. Anything vaguely container-shaped was left out to collect rainwater, and Cornelis, meanwhile, had set out to begin collecting all the available weapons, and although nobody noticed, he was also twirling his mustache. 323 years from this point, a World War II vet named William Golding would write a novel about a group of British schoolboys who found themselves stranded on an uninhabited island and try to set up a little local government, which almost immediately devolves into a brutally violent campaign of us versus them. And yes, they did end up murdering each other, but that's just a story. I wouldn't read anything into that. Now, that said, Cornelis had begun creating... his own local government and then staffing the most important jobs with like-minded associates and friendlies. Remember back when we were anchored in South Africa and he was grumbling about Pelsaert? Well, what I didn't tell you was that during the voyage, all of them had been secretly grumbling together and collecting other grumblers who shared a vision of seizing control of the ship. The plan, simply enough, was to kill Pelsart and his men, overpower 200 soldiers, throw anyone who raised an eyebrow overboard, steal the ship, treasure and all, and then sail the seven seas for the rest of their days as pirates. I'm not making that up. This was plan A. And the problem, of course, was that now that Plan A was securely in the toilet, they knew that if eventually they were rescued and even one of those people blabbed about Plan A, they were probably going to be executed for it. So, meet Plan B. The only challenge to his authority were the soldiers and any husky gentlemen remaining, so he hatched a plan. Cornelis ordered 22 soldiers and some of the other potential agitators to take a boat and sail about 9 kilometers or 5.5 miles to what would become known as West Wallaby Island in the name of searching for food and water. It wasn't going to be a quick trip, and more to the point, Cornelis expected them to rot and die in a big heap under the sweltering sun. Geronimos Cornelis was not a people person. The problem was, not only did they pose this unacceptable threat to his power, they were also sponging up precious supplies. And not just them. There were others he cast away like puppets to surrounding rocky sockets and islands for a host of imaginary reasons, pretty much just to prove he could. In all, about 40 people left this way. And much like a Jim Jones archetype, he convinced his followers that everyone else was the enemy and needed to be purged for the greater good. Cornelis convinced his band of loyal followers that if someone seemed sketchy or appeared already halfway to death's door, how and why did they deserve the privilege of staying alive just to waste supplies on? So, murder was on the table, and not only was it justified, it was necessary. Then, it got to be tested, when two men were accused of breaking open a barrel of wine and getting drunk. Explaining how basically they had taken this right out of everyone's mouths was a pretty easy story to accept, and their murders were handled quietly under the cover of night while everyone else slept. The next batch to be dispatched were dragged out to sea on a raft for some innocent-sounding reason, and then, once safely out of sight of the island, their hands and feet were bound and they were thrown into the sea. Now, for the other survivors on the island, it would take a while for people to begin to realize that the island was starting to become roomier, which was more than enough time for Kanellis to solidify the plot for his reign of terror. Anyone healthy enough to put up a fight? Stab. The sick, weak, or wounded? Stab. Women and children? Stab, stab. Literally, witnesses of any kind? Stab, stabbity, stab. and the reasons why they were doing it became less and less important as the body count rose. Cornelis had been ordering executions and selecting the victims, and his followers seemed okay with it, to the point where it seems like they started to grow an affection for neck-slitting and then drowning people while Cornelis held back and kept his hands Charles Manson clean. And when I say keeping his hands clean, there was a surviving story where he actually tried to poison an infant, but he sucked at it, so he had another one of his followers finish the job. He was the self-appointed mayor of the worst place in the entire southern hemisphere. And the more potential resistance he removed, the closer he became to a living god. Meet the original Lord of the Flies. Except he didn't just blurt out, let's murder everyone. No, instead, he slowly masterminded this evil mental fearscape based on obedience and suspicion. Kind of a real, what would you do for a Klondike bar situation, but with little drabs of water and psychological manipulation rather than mint and chocolate. The murders were always prefaced with some random refusal of theft or whatever, so the mutineers and survivors lived under a shared dark cloud of constant fear that any one of them could be next. And, this will sound weird to say, but killing this many people is hungry work, and they were creating a huge pile of corpses, and they weren't eating any of them. Too much time in the sun had started to make Cornelis weird, weirder. And I don't just mean the loyalty oaths and the superpowers. He'd obviously been building a kind of a hierarchy around himself, and membership had its privileges. The only way to get close to food and weapons and even access to captive women for recreational purposes could all be yours. He went so far as to tell his people that they now lived above and beyond all earthly concepts of authority, or even company laws, or even their original religious backgrounds. He was the Lizard King now. And remember Lucretia von dem Eilen? He had her scrubbed and then took her as his private concubine against her will. She figured it was mildly better than death, and there was always the chance that maybe Cornelis would die of heatstroke or something equally pleasing. So, your boat comprehensively dismantled itself on a reef. You found yourself on a featureless, uninhabited island. Your fellow survivors are going feral. You've been here less than 15 minutes, and the sun, hunger, and thirst are making you stupid. Would you know what to do? They say you can live up to 3 minutes without air, about 3 days without water, about 11 days without sleep, and about 3 weeks without food. Now on a desert island, dehydration, exposure, and injury and mental breakdown are actually way bigger threats than just simple starvation. So most survival experts rank your priorities as shelter or shade, then water, then signaling for rescue, then food. Sunlight speeds dehydration, and a bad enough sunburn will make you hallucinate before you die, and I do not mean from skin cancer. The sun can incapacitate, so your first job is to cover as much of your skin as possible. If you have anything you can use to create shade, like clothes or sails or debris, you really want to keep at least your head, neck, and shoulders covered. If there's any greenery available, maybe you could weave it together to create a kind of a hat or a sunblock. It wouldn't have to win any awards. At worst, if you were to dig into the sand, you might find mud or clay, which you could use like a paste to cover your skin, like Schwarzenegger hiding from the predator, except it's you hiding from the sun, and then just reapply as necessary. Now, obviously, water, water everywhere, Do not drink a drop. Ocean water is about 3.5% salt, which doesn't really sound like much, but your kidneys would strongly disagree. They can't process that, so you end up hemorrhaging more water than you gain, which only speeds all the hallucinations and death. And don't ask me why I know this, but drinking urine would do the same. So using anything you have to collect any potential rainwater is a great idea. In fact, if you have a raft or a plastic sheet, anything like that, If you hang it up, condensation from the local humidity will form on the inside, which you can collect. I know it doesn't sound like much, and it's not, so you're going to need to limit your activity and preserve any moisture left in your body. Little tricks like resting during the day when it's the hottest, and remembering that you actually lose less moisture when you breathe through your nose than your mouth. So, let's say you have no water, but you're surrounded by food. Well, if it's fruit, Great, that contains its own moisture, and I'm gonna say would probably be the most delicious thing you ever eat in your entire life. The problem is, if the only thing you had on the island was bread or carbs or literally anything that needs proper digestion that doesn't contain its own moisture, that's only gonna make everything way worse because your body needs moisture to digest. Now, surviving won't be worth much if no one ever finds you, And most castaways actually die because rescuers would pass right by them without noticing, so make yourself easy to find. Use your imagination and whatever you have available to make something unnatural on the sand. Any kind of thing that would make a rescuer say, oh, you don't normally see an island with a giant arrow on it. And the next part is the actual most important. You need to keep your head on straight. You don't know how long you're going to be there, so you need to establish a routine and keep track of the days and set goals for yourself. Just stay busy and you will be okay. As for some fellow deranged survivor coming over with a knife and a recipe book, remember that a handful of sand in the eyes will disable an attacker and then just simply apply a strong chop to their throat and now you can use them as a bench. The killings on Beacon Island continued for weeks. It was the survival of the worst. with a death toll now as high as 125 people. They actually kind of lost count. And with as many as 40 or more marooned on other islands to waste away and die, there was no one really left to interfere with Plan C. Plan Z was, as soon as a rescue vessel arrived, they planned to board it, take over, kill everyone, load it up with the silver from the Batavia, and bum around Asia pirating other vessels for the rest of their days. Given the opportunity, he would also like to build a new kingdom or settlement somewhere where the Dutch didn't have any authority. Now, off topic, we should really check on that party of soldiers and all the other agitators that got sent off to West Wallaby to die. Well, instead of pulling onto shore and digging their own graves, what they found, when compared to Beacon, was practically Eden. First, they found natural springs and rock pools of beautiful, delicious, life-sustaining water, chilled to a perfect sipping temperature. Oh, and snacks. And I don't just mean the cornucopia of fish and shellfish and oysters that surrounded them. And I don't even mean all the seabirds for roasting and the fresh eggs for breakfast. No, there were also something called tamar wallaby fricassee. Picture a kind of a chonky kangaroo that got hit with a shrink ray until it was about the size of a good-sized cat and then cooked up like venison or beef. They were spoiled with options. They had arrived at a place where you could eat for a month and never have the same meal twice. And the men did honestly try to start sending smoke signals to let everyone on Beacon know that they were safe. But that was when survivors from Beacon started washing up, screaming about the massacre. And there was a man among them named Weeva Hayes, who they elected as their new leader. While Cornelis was waiting for a rescue ship to carjack, more and more refugees had managed to escape and made their way to West Wallaby. And once there, all nicely fed and rehydrated, the soldiers and survivors were becoming a force to commend with, and Cornelis knew that they would have zero issues ratting him out if they saw a rescue ship first, so they had to go. Weeba and company got to work fortifying Wallaby against an incoming attack and improvising weapons. They were able to fashion spears by splitting planks attached to huge 14-16 inch long carpenter nails. For closer combat, they made bats and clubs spiked with them. They were even able to create primitive metal throwing stars. And I'll always say this, never underestimate the defensive power of a simple rock. And they were going to need them, because Cornelis' men showed up and were met with fist-sized rocks, lobbed by angry men who had done nothing but pound barbecue and do push-ups waiting for their arrival. And it did not go well for them. Twice. And at that point, Cornelis, egomaniac that he was, believed that he could charm and manipulate this group and showed up in person. And as soon as he started his spiel about negotiation and exchanges of supplies, Weeba said, hey, let me stop you right there, and then killed a bunch of Cornelis' men and captured him alive. One of his men was able to escape back to Beacon to tell the story, and his name was Wouter Loos. And once he finished his story... The remaining mutineers elected him as their new leader to lead a final attack, and this time they brought their muskets. This would be their final assault, September the 17th, 1629. The battle lasted hours, and by battle, I mean the mutineers taking potshots at the soldiers pinned down behind a wall like a carnival game. They repelled them again and again, but now Hay's position was vulnerable, and their very survival was in question. A few of his men had already been killed, and it was at this moment that one of those impossible moments that make history so damned interesting happened. In the middle of the fight, someone pointed and squinted and spotted a sail. It was the Sardam, a rescue ship from Batavia with Francesco Pelsart on board. Oh my god, both factions launched boats towards the approaching ship immediately. Whoever reached it first was going to control the story, and if the mutineers got there first, they might claim that Hayes was a maniac and a rebel and potentially seize the vessel. Fortunately for history, Hayes' men reached the Sardim first and the entire conspiracy was exposed. All that fried seabird really paid off in a rowing contest. And when the mutineers arrived, they did not find smiling faces. You'd actually be surprised how many cannons you can point at something as small as a rowboat. And the mutineers quickly surrendered. The most notorious mutiny and massacre in maritime history was over. After months of starvation and murder, the entire outcome came down to a paddling race between two small boats across a couple of miles of ocean. Since Pelsart left, of the 230 people left on the island, 125 had been murdered, raped, and tortured. The normal thing to do would be to drag everyone back for trial in Europe, but Pelsaert did not want to be hauling back prisoners. Pelsaert did not have that kind of patience, and ordered a field court right there in the sand. Worth pointing out, under Dutch law at the time, in cases this weird, confessions were required. And the most popular way to obtain those confessions was torture. Cornelis and six of his most enthusiastic accomplices were sentenced to death. Before that, the first step was they took ownership of all of their worldly possessions, from their finances to their laundry, all of it. Then they were fitted for a noose. But before they got to test it, first each man would have their right hand amputated. And you probably imagine the quick swing of a sword or an axe and a little bit of yelling. Well, you wish. One by one, each of the men's hands were slowly chiseled off with a hammer. And then, just to make sure they didn't bleed to death, their wrists were painfully cinched closed. Except for Kanellis. This guy had to give up both paws. Which made the rest of the men laugh. They've been calling him a seducer of men, and they even went so far to ask that he be killed first just so they could watch. Clearly, there was no love lost by this point. and Cornelis remained defiant to the last, demanding justice and shouting for revenge. Cornelis inhaled deeply to continue, when Pelsart had had enough, said, okay, buh-bye, gave a signal for the men to swing, before picking up one of Cornelis' severed hands, holding it to his ear, and saying, I'm sorry, were you saying something? Now to add more insult to injury, the custom at the time was to just leave the gallows and the bodies standing exactly the way they were. They did it to serve as a warning to others and to give the seabirds and crabs something to nibble and peck at, which they did for the next six weeks or so as the crews moved the cargo and wealth from the wreck of the Batavia. The remaining 16 of Cornelis' followers were not offered the immediacy of a quick death. Said in quotes, meaning quick in the sense that an oil change is considered quick. No, these men were spared and brought back to Indonesia, provided they survived the trip. See, on the way, they were flogged and whipped and beaten and dropped from the yardarm. And they were even keel-hauled. It's that thing where they tie you to a rope and then rub you around the outside of the ship. All 16 were interrogated, tortured, convicted, and executed in a variety of popular ways. Everything from hanging, to beheading, to dismemberment and amputation. One of Cornell's senior lieutenants, Jacob Peters, was reportedly broken on the wheel. I don't know if you know that one. Imagine being tied to a wooden frame with your arms and your legs spread out, and an executioner type uses a heavy iron bar or a giant hammer to shatter your arms and legs. Once they're all loosened up, they're woven through the spokes of a large wheel, still alive, and then just put on display, like a pre-industrial industrial accident slash ethics lesson. For reasons two of the mutineers, Walter Luce and a cabin boy named Jan Pilgrim Dubai, became the first known Europeans forced to try and settle the Australian mainland. They were put ashore with a few supplies, marooned, and summarily disappeared from the historical record. Adrian Jacobs, the ship's skipper, was arrested and spent the rest of his life in prison. Francisco Pelsart spent the rest of his life defending himself and catching flak for his decision to leave everyone on Beacon in order to save them, of course, Which was uncomfortable, but it wasn't a long life. He died from illness the following year, in 1630. Weeba Hayes and the other soldiers were treated as heroes and were promoted for their bravery. About 282 survived the wreck. I say about because the records from 1629 ain't great. We know that about 20 died from thirst or sickness, and 125 were murdered. Literally the only incident worse than this would happen about 150 years later, when the British slave ship Zong threw more than 130 enslaved Africans overboard just to try to collect insurance money. About 74 souls were saved from the islands, including several surviving women and a single child. The Batavia became one of the most famous cases of cult leadership in history. It was an incredible tale of ordinary people finding themselves trapped with a maniac with unchecked power, living under a strict system of control and threat. And incredibly, if the sardom had arrived just a few hours later, The mutineers would have likely overwhelmed Weeba's forces, and then just made up any story they liked, before turning around and stealing the rescue ship, and piling a whole lot more bodies on the island. Since the time the Sardom sailed away, and until this very day, the islands have remained abandoned, except for the bodies, and the wreck, and the ruins of Haystone Fort, which are still there. The Batavia was more than a shipwreck. It represented a showcase of all of the horrible realities of living in the 1700s combined with the horrors of human ambition and greed and selfishness. Cornelius used a Machiavellian power combo of peer pressure, self-interest, and fear to transform hundreds of ordinary people into murderers. And all it took was that little bit of bad math to reveal the fragility of the human mind when pushed to the limits of survival by said maniac. This became one of the most notorious mutinies and massacres in maritime history. Especially, but not limited to the fact, that this massive regal ship was on her maiden voyage. The Batavia's entire operational career consisted of a single journey and became the darkest and most deadly shipwreck in Australian history. The Batavia shipwreck and massacre of 1629 remains to this day one of history's most shocking episodes of maritime violence ever recorded. most shocking episodes of violence ever recorded in the history of human maritime travel. This was definitely one of the weirder tales we've ever told, and that is saying a lot. Can you even imagine trying to travel thousands of kilometers for the better part of a year across three different oceans only to find yourself getting clubbed or sliced to death or just being held underwater for too long? Probably the most incredible thing about it was how more people died after reaching safety than during the shipwreck itself. In normal circumstances, this shipwreck alone would have been an incredible story, but by the end, I even forget that there was a shipwreck. And like I kept saying, the math on the numbers of bodies is 400 years old, and not that well preserved. But of the 280 that survived the wreck, only about 70 made it to their final port of call. And the reason was, Cornelis, he really saw people as a means to an end. And I can't help but notice that if he had been an animal, like a lion or a shark or a gator or something, he would have been summarily hunted down and killed to protect people. Which they did, and I think that it's only because this story did happen 400 years ago, we were guaranteed a bit of a show and a fairly satisfying price for this monster to pay. If this story had happened today, I would be afraid of what a good lawyer would have done for him. This story would have been a lot easier to accept if it had turned out that he had just been a master of hypnotism. and it makes me feel like, man, I wish I could just hypnotize or bully you into supporting the show, but it's just not in my nature. I only really want you to have a little laugh while learning a little history, and then feeling a little safer by the time you're done. However, if it is in your nature to want to manipulate people into becoming subservient pen pals or content slaves or even future organ donors by throwing a couple of bucks their way, I hear and obey. You are always welcome to share a small donation to help with the ongoing production of the show over at buymeacoffee.com slash doomsday. But if you were looking to update your resume with a producer credit for the show, head on over to patreon.com slash funeral kazoo. And you can happily put me down as a reference. Quick but heartfelt shout out to Raven Evensong, Sabrina Pfister, King of the Reds Rory Bennett, Mira Boulding, Lisa Ambercrombie, Mistakes Were Made, and of course, like the phoenix rising from the ashes, Catherine White, for helping support me on Patreon. Older episodes can be found wherever you found this one, and while you're there, please leave us a review and tell your friends. I don't have a budget to spend on letting people know about the show, so your kind word of mouth or sharing is all I got. I always thank all my supporters, new and old, for their support and encouragement. But if you could spare the money and had to choose, I always ask you to consider making a donation to GlobalMedic. Global Medic is a rapid response agency of Canadian volunteers offering assistance around the world to aid in the aftermath of disasters and crises. They're often the first and sometimes only team to get critical interventions to people in life-threatening situations, and to date they have helped over 6 million people across 89 different countries. You can learn more and donate at globalmedic.ca. On the next episode... It can be hard for young people to find a job in 2026. But children had zero problem finding work in 1911. In fact, the biggest threat to your ongoing employment was potentially getting your pay docked for leaping from a window engulfed in flames. It's the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory Fire and Disaster... of 1911. We'll talk soon. Safety goggles off, and thanks for listening.


